Debi called Evon Handras of the NYCFCI to see if she could find someone to respond, as Debi could not get there until much later in the day after the staff would be gone. To make matters worse, it had started to rain steadily. The Alliance’s Jenny Coffey overheard the conversation in the Alliance office and immediately reached out to one of her contacts at a nearby real estate office, who was willing to keep the kittens safe and warm until rescue arrived. A school employee, Faith, agreed to deliver the kittens to the real estate office while we tried to find someone to carry them on the next leg of their journey.
In the meanwhile, Evon reached out to NYCFCI colleague, Valerie Sicignano, and she found a volunteer who was willing to pick up the kitties at the real estate office. Evon also called Ashot Karamian of All About Spay Neuter, who via his well-connected network, within minutes arranged for nearby rescuer, Susan St. John from Cats in the Cradle Rescue, to meet Faith at the real estate office for the kitty handover.
With a clean bill of health and a top-notch behavioral assessment, the brothers — now named Rusty and Nacho in honor of their fabulous colors — were moved to a Cats in the Cradle Rescue foster home to await adoption. What a happy new beginning for these two gorgeous and lucky orange tabbies!
Word has it that the kittens are even more friendly, loving, and affectionate than they were when they first arrived. They will make awesome additions to some lucky family!
If you’re interested in adopting Nacho and/or Rusty, visit the Cats in the Cradle Rescue Petfinder page.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/94e4b/94e4bbbc2bd910dbbaadc438303d90b3a44d02eb" alt="Rusty and his brother Nacho were found in a sealed trash bag by an eagle-eyed school custodian. (Photo by Cats in the Cradle Rescue)"
These beautiful little babies were found dumped inside of a black garbage bag by a school janitor. He was cleaning things up when he saw the bag move. Inside were these babies.
They are friendly. They were obviously the last kittens that someone’s cat had and they couldn’t find a home for them, so they condemned them to either a slow death by suffocation, or an equally horrific death being crushed in the maw of a garbage truck.
I wish this horrific act was beyond imagination, but all too often people fail to take responsibility for their pets or their own actions and act in the most selfish and heartless manner.
If you see a garbage bag moving and it doesn’t have any holes ripped in it, there may just be a kitten or puppy inside. Please don’t just walk by. Take a moment to investigate and possibly save a life.
– Susan St. John, Cats in the Cradle Rescue